Closest match · Lasts longest
Find on AmazonALT FragrancesBeach Side
for Maison Margiela Replica Beach Walk
8 accuracy · 9 longevity · $45
Brand Guide
Best Maison Margiela Dupes
Maison Margiela alternatives, clones, and replicas — ranked by accuracy.
Matches checked Jan 2026 – Oct 2026 · 8 of 14 in Oct
Maison Margiela's Replica line clones well across accessible brands — Jazz Club, By the Fireplace and Beach Walk anchor alternatives from Zara, ALT Fragrances, Lattafa and Dua Fragrances. Below are all 14 matches we list for 6 Maison Margiela fragrances, grouped by the original: 7 scored by owners, 6 provisional and 1 not scored yet. Accuracy and longevity are rated separately, never averaged. We take no brand deals.
6 originals14 matches7 owner-scoredNo brand deals
Best value at 7+
Find on AmazonDua FragrancesDua’s Fireplace
for Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace
8 accuracy · – longevity · $35–$65
At a glance: the top match for each
| Original | Top-ranked match | From | Accuracy · longevity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Replica Jazz Club | ALT Fragrances SaxophoneThe Scent File Pick | $45 | 8 · 8 |
| Replica By the Fireplace | Dua Fragrances Dua’s FireplaceThe Scent File Pick | $35 | 8 · not reported |
| Replica Beach Walk | ALT Fragrances Beach SideThe Scent File Pick | $45 | 8 · 9 |
| Replica Coffee Break | ALT Fragrances CaféThe Scent File Pick | $45 | 7 · 5 |
| Replica Under the Lemon Trees | Zara Lemon & MuskHighest-scored match | $12 | 6 · 6 provisional |
| Replica Flower Market | Zara Rose GourmandHighest-scored match | $12 | 7 · 6 provisional |
Maison Margiela Replica Jazz Club Dupes
Full Replica Jazz Club dupes guide →Replica Jazz Club profile & scores →
$170The originalBuy on Amazon
ALT Fragrances
SaxophoneThe Scent File Pick
Four reviewers who know Jazz Club compare the two: three find it the same or nearly so and stronger, and one who has both says similar but not a good dupe. Wear time is reported at about eight hours on skin and days on clothes.
Accuracy8
Longevity8
Tobacco Collection Rich Warm AddictiveCheapest with a scoreProvisional
Budget rum-tobacco-vanilla sketch in Jazz Club's territory; short wear but recognizable opening at a fraction of the price.
RedditWhat it clones
Accuracy7
Longevity6
$15–$25Find on Amazon
Oakcha
Speakeasy
Eight reviewers who know Jazz Club compare the two: six find it close, around eighty-five percent, creamier and without the smoke, and two say it is lacking or not like it. Wear time is about six hours on skin.
Accuracy7
Longevity6
$32.95Find on Amazon
Dua Fragrances
Jazz
Dua Fragrances sells Jazz as inspired by Maison Margiela Jazz Club.
No score yet
Dua Fragrances
Dua’s FireplaceThe Scent File Pick
Two owners compare it with By the Fireplace: one who owns both calls it remarkably accurate and a little more potent, the other puts it at about 90 percent after an odd first half hour. Nobody has reported how long it wears.
Accuracy8
LongevityNot reported yet
$35–$65Find on Amazon
ALT Fragrances
Fireside MarshmallowLongest wear
Two reviewers who know By the Fireplace compare the two: one says it smells a lot like it, the other finds it a more wearable take. It is reported as long lasting, twelve hours and more on skin.
Accuracy7
Longevity8
Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud
About eighty-five reviewers who know By the Fireplace compare the two. Roughly half find it similar, a sweeter and less smoky take; a fifth call it related but clearly different side by side; a quarter say it smells nothing like it. It is strong and long lasting for most, eight hours and more, and several say it needs months to settle.
Accuracy6
Longevity8
$25–$40Find on Amazon
ApplewoodCheapest with a scoreProvisional
Budget-tier smoky-sweet wood sketch; recognizable family but thinner and shorter than Margiela.
FragranticaWhat it clones
Accuracy6
Longevity5
$15–$30Find on Amazon
ALT Fragrances
Beach SideThe Scent File Pick
One reviewer who compared it with a sample of Beach Walk calls them identical, with this one much stronger and still going after twelve hours. A single comparison so far.
Accuracy8
Longevity9
P
Perfumology
No. 103Provisional
Coconut-driven solar with cedar undertone; a decent budget take though slightly sweeter than the original.
Fragrantica
Accuracy7
Longevity6
$30–$50Find on Amazon
Sunset DreamsCheapest with a scoreProvisional
Budget solar-coconut sketch that Zara fans frequently flag as Beach Walk adjacent despite shorter wear.
Fragrantica
Accuracy7
Longevity5
$15–$30Find on Amazon
ALT Fragrances
CaféThe Scent File Pick
Five owners compare it with Coffee Break: three find it very close, one misses the creaminess, and one says it turned plasticky on skin. Wearers report about five hours.
Accuracy7
Longevity5
Lemon & MuskHighest-scored match
Clean lemon-musk scent in the same citrus-fresh family; simpler than Margiela's but pleasant for everyday wear.
RedditWhat it clones
Accuracy6
Longevity6
$12–$26Find on Amazon
Rose GourmandHighest-scored match
A budget floral that echoes Flower Market's rose-forward character with a subtle gourmand twist.
Accuracy7
Longevity6
$12–$26Find on Amazon
We also list 13 more Maison Margiela fragrances with no verified match yet. See them on the Maison Margiela page →