Replica Under the Lemon Trees vs By the Fireplace
Side by side. Scored honestly.
← Compare different fragrances

Side by side
Comparing the originals — price, breadth, listed-note depth.
Bright and almost edible in the opening — lemon and mandarin hit clean and tart, lifted by a sharp green snap of basil that keeps it from reading as simple citrus. The heart softens quickly; cedar and vetiver ground it without going woody or heavy, just adding enough texture to prevent the whole thing from evaporating in twenty minutes. Projection is modest and close-to-skin throughout. The dry-down is a quiet white musk with a faint citrus memory underneath — soft, clean, barely-there sillage. — Ideal for warm-weather days when you want to smell like you made an effort without announcing it.
Opens with sharp, medicinal cade oil and birch tar — almost harsh, like doused embers and scorched wood — before incense and smoke soften the edge into something genuinely atmospheric. The heart settles into a warm, resinous amber that binds the smoke rather than sweetening it, while cedarwood and sandalwood push the dry-down toward a dry, woody comfort. Projection is moderate; sillage lingers close to skin after a few hours, leaving a quiet, smoldering trail — Best worn in cold weather by anyone who wants to smell like they've been sitting beside a real fire all evening.
How they overlap
Replica Under the Lemon Trees and By the Fireplace share no notes in common — these two fragrances target very different olfactory territory, and the comparison is a question of which direction you want to go rather than which version of the same accord.
The buying decision
Replica Under the Lemon Trees is the cheaper original at $185 compared to $285 for By the Fireplace — about 35% less.
Recommendation
If you're price-sensitive, Replica Under the Lemon Trees delivers comparable territory at $100 less than By the Fireplace. If you want the specific character of By the Fireplace — the prose above is the better guide than the price — the premium is what you're paying for.