Skip to main content
Comparison

Replica Under the Lemon Trees vs Replica By the Fireplace

Side by side. Scored honestly.

← Compare different fragrances
Notes overlap
Shared

No shared notes — these two land in very different territory.

Unique to Replica Under the Lemon Trees
Unique to Replica By the Fireplace

Side by side

Comparing the originals — price, breadth, listed-note depth.

Original pricetied
$185
Replica Under the Lemon Trees
$185
Replica By the Fireplace
Season coveragetied
2/4
Replica Under the Lemon Trees
2/4
Replica By the Fireplace
Note depthtied
6
Replica Under the Lemon Trees
6
Replica By the Fireplace
What Replica Under the Lemon Trees smells like

Bright and almost edible in the opening — lemon and mandarin hit clean and tart, lifted by a sharp green snap of basil that keeps it from reading as simple citrus. The heart softens quickly; cedar and vetiver ground it without going woody or heavy, just adding enough texture to prevent the whole thing from evaporating in twenty minutes. Projection is modest and close-to-skin throughout. The dry-down is a quiet white musk with a faint citrus memory underneath — soft, clean, barely-there sillage. — Ideal for warm-weather days when you want to smell like you made an effort without announcing it.

What Replica By the Fireplace smells like

Opens with a lightly smoky, almost edible chestnut that reads less like a fireplace and more like roasted nuts cooling on a hearth. Cloves add gentle spice in the heart without turning sharp, while guaiac wood brings a soft, ash-tinged smokiness that anchors the whole thing. The dry-down is where it earns its reputation: vanilla and cashmeran meld into a warm, skin-close marshmallow sweetness that lingers quietly for hours. Projection stays modest — intimate rather than loud, with a close sillage that rewards proximity. — Best worn on cold evenings when you want to smell like somewhere, not something.

How they overlap

Replica Under the Lemon Trees and Replica By the Fireplace share no notes in common — these two fragrances target very different olfactory territory, and the comparison is a question of which direction you want to go rather than which version of the same accord.

The buying decision

Original-bottle pricing is essentially identical ($185 vs $185), so the choice rarely comes down to upfront cost. Replica Under the Lemon Trees is built for spring/summer; Replica By the Fireplace for fall/winter. Pick by when you'd actually wear it.

Recommendation

These two land in genuinely different scent territory — there's no "better" answer, just which direction you want to go. Read the scent descriptions above and pick the one that sounds like you'd want to smell.

Best dupe for each

New dupes in your inbox.

New matches, reformulation alerts, honest scores. No spam.