Carlisle vs Pegasus EDP
Side by side. Scored honestly.
← Compare different fragrances

Side by side
Comparing the originals — price, breadth, listed-note depth.
Opens with a bright, slightly tart apple cut through by snappy ginger and pink pepper — enough spice to keep it from reading sweet. The heart settles into a rose-forward floral warmed by cinnamon, jasmine adding softness without going powdery. Patchouli and benzoin anchor the dry-down into something resinous and skin-close, with moderate sillage that leans intimate rather than room-filling. Projection is confident in the first few hours, then retreats to a quiet, warm trail — apple and spice long gone, patchouli doing the heavy lifting. — A fall and winter fragrance for anyone who wants a polished, approachable oriental without tipping into excess sweetness.
Bergamot opens things up cleanly before stepping aside almost immediately, letting heliotrope and almond take center stage in the heart — a powdery, almost confectionery pairing that reads warm and skin-close rather than sharp. Jasmine adds quiet floral depth without going feminine. The dry-down settles into sandalwood and vanilla, soft and creamy with moderate sillage that stays within a few feet. Projection is polite, longevity solid at six-plus hours. — Best in cold weather on someone who wants a crowd-pleasing, wearable signature that leans sweet without going full dessert.
How they overlap
Carlisle and Pegasus EDP share exactly one note (jasmine). The overlap is real but narrow — most of the wear experience will diverge.
The buying decision
Pegasus EDP is the cheaper original at $265 compared to $385 for Carlisle — about 31% less. Both wear best across the same fall/winter — they're interchangeable on weather fit.
Recommendation
If you're price-sensitive, Pegasus EDP delivers comparable territory at $120 less than Carlisle. If you want the specific character of Carlisle — the prose above is the better guide than the price — the premium is what you're paying for.