What is the best dupe for Carlisle?
Based on owner reports, the highest-accuracy dupe for Carlisle is Cassius by Maison Alhambra — a Spot-on match (8/10 accuracy, longevity 7/10).
The one match we list is Maison Alhambra Cassius. Owners score it 8 for accuracy and 7 for longevity, from $40.
Two separate scores, never averaged: how close it smells, and how long it lasts.
Every pairing shows where it comes from and how far we trust it.
Twenty-eight owners compare it with Carlisle and nearly all find it very close, several after side-by-side wear, with a harsher opening and less depth; three put it only in the same ballpark. Most wearers report five to ten hours, and some say it is weaker than the original.
“I am wearing this on one arm and Carlisle on the other. It is hard to tell between them.”
Wear Cassius or Carlisle? Tell us how they compare. Reports like yours are what move a match up a level.
Carlisle has one match so far. These are the closest scents by shared notes that have several.
Opens with a bright, slightly tart apple cut through by snappy ginger and pink pepper — enough spice to keep it from reading sweet. The heart settles into a rose-forward floral warmed by cinnamon, jasmine adding softness without going powdery. Patchouli and benzoin anchor the dry-down into something resinous and skin-close, with moderate sillage that leans intimate rather than room-filling. Projection is confident in the first few hours, then retreats to a quiet, warm trail — apple and spice long gone, patchouli doing the heavy lifting. — A fall and winter fragrance for anyone who wants a polished, approachable oriental without tipping into excess sweetness.
The closest match, Maison Alhambra Cassius, scores accuracy 8 for $40–$60 — a small gap. For most buyers the dupe captures the scent; the original mainly buys you the bottle, the brand experience, and the last-phase nuance a budget formula tends to simplify.
The top dupe of Parfums de Marly's Carlisle is Cassius by Maison Alhambra, scoring 8/10 for accuracy and 7/10 for longevity. At $40, it's an 80% match to the $460 original — saving roughly $420 per bottle. It's the only scored dupe of Carlisle so far, with more on the way as community evidence accumulates.
Based on owner reports, the highest-accuracy dupe for Carlisle is Cassius by Maison Alhambra — a Spot-on match (8/10 accuracy, longevity 7/10).
Dupes are rated on two independent dimensions: scent accuracy (how closely it matches the original) and longevity (how long it lasts on skin). Scores come from owner reports on Reddit r/fragrance, r/fragranceclones and Fragrantica, and each is marked community-scored, provisional or not scored. They are never averaged into a single number — accuracy and longevity are separate decisions.
No. The Scent File takes no brand deals, no sponsorships, and no paid rankings. Rankings follow the scores only. We do earn affiliate commission when you purchase through our links at no extra cost to you — but this never influences which dupes appear or how they are scored.
The 30 best-tested dupes under $40, as a PDF. You join our email list too: rare emails, no spam.