
LegacyThe Scent File Pick
Widely called the closest budget Blue Talisman — “much better dupe” and “super similar” from owner-of-both reports. Longevity is contested (ranges from a weak ~2h to all-day).
We list it as a match for one original, Ex Nihilo Blue Talisman. Owners score it 7 for accuracy and 7 for longevity, from $40. The Scent File Pick for Blue Talisman is Maison Asrar Legacy.

Two separate scores, never averaged: how close it smells, and how long it lasts.
Against Ex Nihilo Blue Talisman, Jo Milano Game of Spades Black Sapphire scores accuracy 7 — recognizable but not identical. A strong buy if you want the vibe cheaply; if that scent is a daily signature, the original keeps a real edge on precision.
Every pairing shows where it comes from and how far we trust it.
Jo Milano’s take on Blue Talisman Extrait. In a side-by-side with the original extrait one owner found the opening close but the dry-down more linear and citrus-led; another found their bottle very similar to the original.
“when I compared this side by side to the original extrait, black sapphire misses in the dry down.”
Wear Game of Spades Black Sapphire or Blue Talisman? Tell us how they compare. Reports like yours are what move a match up a level.
The first 3 of the other 6 matches we list for Ex Nihilo Blue Talisman, in our ranking.

Widely called the closest budget Blue Talisman — “much better dupe” and “super similar” from owner-of-both reports. Longevity is contested (ranges from a weak ~2h to all-day).

Yom & Layl markets it as a Blue Talisman dupe; vendor owner-of-both reviews call it a near-mirror, but independent editorial notes it skews sweeter and lacks the base depth of the original.

The most-discussed budget option, but a loose match — owner-of-both reports note sweet-vs-sour pear differences and call it “in the vibe” rather than a true clone. Strong longevity.
The 30 best-tested dupes under $40, as a PDF. You join our email list too: rare emails, no spam.