Is Onyx Silver Worth It?
We list it as a match for one original, Parfums de Marly Castley. One owner report scores it 7 for accuracy and 6 for longevity, from $35.
Two separate scores, never averaged: how close it smells, and how long it lasts.
Is Khadlaj Onyx Silver ($35–$50) worth it?
Against Parfums de Marly Castley, Khadlaj Onyx Silver scores accuracy 7 — recognizable but not identical. A strong buy if you want the vibe cheaply; if that scent is a daily signature, the original keeps a real edge on precision.
Why we list this match
Every pairing shows where it comes from and how far we trust it.
- 1Listed, not scoredA source names the pairing. We show no number.
- 2ProvisionalScored, but with no source you can open and check.
- 3Community-scoredScored from owner reports, with a source you can open.
One detailed source notes it opens like Louis Vuitton Imagination before settling into Castley's DNA — 'lies close to the same DNA... often perceived as slightly softer, cleaner, more soapy-fresh.'
- Source
- Fragrantica
- See it yourself
- fragrantica.com
- Evidence
- 1 owner report
- Last checked
- Sep 2026
Wear Onyx Silver or Castley? Tell us how they compare. Reports like yours are what move a match up a level.
Khadlaj Onyx Silver — frequently asked
- What does Khadlaj Onyx Silver clone?
- Khadlaj Onyx Silver is community-matched to 1 original: Parfums de Marly Castley (accuracy 7/10). Accuracy (closeness) and longevity (wear time) are scored separately from owner reports, never averaged.
- Is Khadlaj Onyx Silver worth it?
- Against Parfums de Marly Castley, Khadlaj Onyx Silver scores accuracy 7 — recognizable but not identical. A strong buy if you want the vibe cheaply; if that scent is a daily signature, the original keeps a real edge on precision. It runs about $350 less than the original.
- How is Khadlaj Onyx Silver scored?
- Accuracy and longevity are scored separately on a 1–10 scale, sourced from community owner reports on Reddit and Fragrantica — never averaged, never sponsored. The Scent File takes no brand deals.