
Karus Secret MuskThe Scent File Pick
Three Reddit owners call it a spot-on or one-to-one match for Arabians Tonka, and no one who has tried both disagrees. Nobody has reported how long it lasts next to the original yet.
We list it as a match for one original, Montale Arabians Tonka. It is provisionally scored 6 for accuracy and 7 for longevity, from $30: we don't yet have a source for those scores that you can check. The Scent File Pick for Arabians Tonka is Khadlaj Karus Secret Musk.
Provisional scores: no source for them that you can check yet.
Against Montale Arabians Tonka, Al Haramain Amber Oud Dubai Nights has a provisional accuracy 6 — a score we can't yet back with a source you can check. At $30–$60 versus $190, it's a low-risk way to sample the style, not a verified match.
Every pairing shows where it comes from and how far we trust it.
Clearly inspired by Montale Arabians Tonka but fresher and less intense — a same-vibe interpretation rather than a 1:1.
What is missing: a source for these scores that you can open and check. Until we have one, the scores are drawn hatched, not solid.
Wear Amber Oud Dubai Nights or Arabians Tonka? Tell us how they compare. Reports like yours are what move a match up a level.
The other match we list for Montale Arabians Tonka, in our ranking.

Three Reddit owners call it a spot-on or one-to-one match for Arabians Tonka, and no one who has tried both disagrees. Nobody has reported how long it lasts next to the original yet.
The 30 best-tested dupes under $40, as a PDF. You join our email list too: rare emails, no spam.