
Karus Secret MuskThe Scent File Pick
Three Reddit owners call it a spot-on or one-to-one match for Arabians Tonka, and no one who has tried both disagrees. Nobody has reported how long it lasts next to the original yet.
Our pick is Khadlaj Karus Secret Musk. Owners score it 8 for accuracy, from $25. How long it lasts has not been reported yet. We compare 2 matches below.
“I should’ve saved my money - the Secret Musk is spot on dupe!!”
Scored for how close it smells. Nobody has told us how long it lasts yet.

Three Reddit owners call it a spot-on or one-to-one match for Arabians Tonka, and no one who has tried both disagrees. Nobody has reported how long it lasts next to the original yet.

Clearly inspired by Montale Arabians Tonka but fresher and less intense — a same-vibe interpretation rather than a 1:1.
Tonka and vanilla take the lead immediately, thick and almost edible, with labdanum adding a dark resinous sweetness that keeps it from tipping into dessert territory. The oud is restrained here — more smoky warmth than barnyard funk — anchoring the heart alongside sandalwood's creamy dry wood. By the dry-down, amber and musk fuse everything into a close, skin-hugging veil that lingers for hours without broadcasting. Moderate projection, exceptional longevity, and a texture that feels genuinely luxurious. — Built for cold weather and late evenings; ideal for anyone who wants comfort without sweetness overload.
The top dupe of Montale's Arabians Tonka is Karus Secret Musk by Khadlaj, scoring 8/10 for accuracy. Its longevity has not been reported yet. At $25, it's an 80% match to the $190 original — saving roughly $165 per bottle. Below: 1 more dupe, each marked with how well its score is backed.
Based on owner reports, the highest-accuracy dupe for Arabians Tonka is Karus Secret Musk by Khadlaj — a Spot-on match (8/10 accuracy, longevity not reported yet). If you prioritize longevity over accuracy, sort the matches above by longevity to see the top performer on that axis.
Dupes are rated on two independent dimensions: scent accuracy (how closely it matches the original) and longevity (how long it lasts on skin). Scores come from owner reports on Reddit r/fragrance, r/fragranceclones and Fragrantica, and each is marked community-scored, provisional or not scored. They are never averaged into a single number — accuracy and longevity are separate decisions.
No. The Scent File takes no brand deals, no sponsorships, and no paid rankings. Rankings follow the scores only. We do earn affiliate commission when you purchase through our links at no extra cost to you — but this never influences which dupes appear or how they are scored.
The 30 best-tested dupes under $40, as a PDF. You join our email list too: rare emails, no spam.