What is the best dupe for Black XS?
Based on owner reports, the highest-accuracy dupe for Black XS is Shaghaf Men by Swiss Arabian — a Same vibe match (5/10 accuracy, longevity 6/10).
The one match we list is Swiss Arabian Shaghaf Men. Owners score it 5 for accuracy and 6 for longevity, from $25.
Two separate scores, never averaged: how close it smells, and how long it lasts.
Every pairing shows where it comes from and how far we trust it.
Seventeen owners compare it with Black XS. Six say it copies the Black XS L’Excès flanker instead, six find a fresher, sweeter Black XS, and four find no resemblance. Wearers report three to ten hours.
“I agree with xoxoMyke, this is a nicer clone of Black XS L'Exces, not the original Black XS.”
Wear Shaghaf Men or Black XS? Tell us how they compare. Reports like yours are what move a match up a level.
Black XS has one match so far. These are the closest scents by shared notes that have several.
Opens with a sharp cardamom and pepper bite that gives it some early edge, then settles quickly into a warm amber and vanilla heart that reads more sweet than spicy. Cedar keeps it from going full gourmand, lending a dry, slightly woody backbone through the dry-down. Projection is moderate — noticeable but not aggressive — and sillage trails off into a soft, musky vanilla that clings close to skin for hours. Straightforward and easy to wear, but unremarkable past its decent opening — best for cooler evenings when you want something approachable, warm, and unchallenging.
No dupe here clears accuracy 7 — the best is Swiss Arabian Shaghaf Men at accuracy 5. This is a hard scent to clone, so the original still holds a real edge over the budget field. Worth it if the exact accord is what you're after.
The top dupe of Paco Rabanne's Black XS is Shaghaf Men by Swiss Arabian, scoring 5/10 for accuracy and 6/10 for longevity. At $25, it's a 50% match to the $65 original — saving roughly $40 per bottle. It's the only scored dupe of Black XS so far, with more on the way as community evidence accumulates.
Based on owner reports, the highest-accuracy dupe for Black XS is Shaghaf Men by Swiss Arabian — a Same vibe match (5/10 accuracy, longevity 6/10).
Dupes are rated on two independent dimensions: scent accuracy (how closely it matches the original) and longevity (how long it lasts on skin). Scores come from owner reports on Reddit r/fragrance, r/fragranceclones and Fragrantica, and each is marked community-scored, provisional or not scored. They are never averaged into a single number — accuracy and longevity are separate decisions.
No. The Scent File takes no brand deals, no sponsorships, and no paid rankings. Rankings follow the scores only. We do earn affiliate commission when you purchase through our links at no extra cost to you — but this never influences which dupes appear or how they are scored.
The 30 best-tested dupes under $40, as a PDF. You join our email list too: rare emails, no spam.